Notes-NCERT-Class-8-Social Science-2-Chapter-4-The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society-CBSE

Chapter-4-The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society

NCERT-Class-8-Social Science-II (Exploring Society: India and Beyond)

Notes

Topics to be Learn :

  • Introduction
  • The Foundation of Law and Justice
  • The Architecture of the Indian Judicial System
  • Constitutional Powers and Jurisdictions
  • Specialized Tribunals and Digital Transformation
  • Alternate Modes of Dispute Resolution

Justice and the Judiciary:

The Preamble’s Promise of Justice:

  1. The Preamble of the Indian Constitution promises every citizen social, economic and political justice.
  2. The founders of independent India established a strong judicial system to protect democracy and ensure justice for all.
  3. The Preamble also guarantees the following:
  • Liberty: Freedom of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship.
  • Equality: Equal status and equal opportunities for all.
  • Fraternity: Promotes brotherhood, dignity of individuals and unity of the nation.
  1. The Indian Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949.

Justice – Why It Matters:

  • Justice is important for maintaining peace and harmony in society.
  • It ensures that everyone is treated equally and lives with dignity.

The Judiciary settles disputes and gives fair decisions according to the law.

Three Pillars of Government :

Three Pillars of Government:

The Indian government has three main organs:

Organ Main Function Role of Judiciary
Legislature Makes laws. Checks whether laws follow the Constitution.
Executive Implements and enforces laws. Ensures that the Executive works within its constitutional limits.
Judiciary Interprets laws and settles disputes. Works independently of the Legislature and Executive.

[collapse]

Importance of an Independent Judiciary:

  • An independent Judiciary ensures that everyone gets a fair and just decision.
  • Disputes can arise in personal and professional life.
  • Disputes can be solved through discussion, mediation or by approaching courts.
  • The Constitution provides for separation of powers among the Legislature, Executive and Judiciary.
  • This separation prevents any one organ of government from misusing its powers.

The Connection Between Law and Justice:

From Societies to Governments:

  • As human societies grew larger and more complex, governments were formed to manage them.
  • People expected fair treatment, peace and safety in society.
  • Governments were given the power to make laws and ensure that people follow them.
  • Laws help the government maintain order and provide justice to everyone.

Meaning of Law : Laws are general rules made by the government to control people's activities and maintain discipline in society. They also specify punishments for those who break the laws.

Consequences of Breaking the Law:

A person who breaks the law may face the following consequences:

  1. Fine: Paying money as a penalty.
  2. Compensation: Paying money to the person who has suffered a loss.
  3. Imprisonment: Being sent to prison in serious cases.

Meaning of Judicial System: The Judicial System allows people to complain when they face injustice. It gives both sides an opportunity to present their views and ensures fair decisions according to the law and the Constitution.

Unjust Laws – Lessons from History:

Not all laws are fair. Laws that discriminate against people or violate democratic values must be changed or repealed (cancelled).

Examples of Unjust Laws :

Examples of Unjust Laws:

Country / Law What it did Status
India – Criminal Tribes Act, 1871 Wrongly labelled certain communities as criminals by birth. Repealed
India – Vernacular Press Act, 1878 Restricted the freedom of newspapers published in Indian languages. Repealed
USA – Jim Crow Laws Discriminated against African Americans and stopped them from using public facilities reserved for white people. Repealed in the 1960s
South Africa – Apartheid Laws Discriminated against people on the basis of race and denied equal rights and dignity to non-white people. Repealed in 1991

[collapse]

Colonial-Era Laws in India :

  • After independence, India reviewed many laws made during British rule.
  • Many of these laws were discriminatory and against democratic values.
  • The Indian government has repealed more than 1,500 colonial-era laws.
  • These laws were removed because they went against the principles of justice, equality and democracy.

Two Aspects of Justice:

Justice has two important aspects: Substantive Justice and Procedural Justice.

  • A person who faces injustice may expect punishment, an apology or compensation.
  • The accused person should also get a fair chance to explain their side.

(1) Substantive Justice:

  • Substantive Justice focuses on the final result or outcome of a case.
  • It checks whether the decision is fair, just and reasonable.
  • The punishment or compensation should be fair and suitable for the offence.

Example: Giving proper compensation, a refund or fair punishment to the affected person.

(2) Procedural Justice:

  • Procedural Justice focuses on the process followed to reach a decision.
  • Every person involved must get a fair chance to present their side.
  • Every person is considered innocent until proven guilty. This is called the Presumption of Innocence.

Example: Both Anita and her employer get an equal opportunity to present their cases in court.

Difference Between Substantive and Procedural Justice :

Difference Between Substantive and Procedural Justice:

Substantive Justice Procedural Justice
Focuses on the final result. Focuses on the process of decision-making.
Checks whether the decision is fair. Checks whether everyone gets a fair hearing.
Ensures a fair outcome. Ensures a fair procedure.
Example: Giving proper compensation or punishment. Example: Giving both sides an opportunity to present their cases.

Remember: Substantive Justice means fair decision, while Procedural Justice means fair process.

[collapse]

The Judicial System in India:

India has a unified judicial system with different levels of courts. These courts work in a hierarchical order, from the highest court to the local courts.

Hierarchy of Courts in India:

There are three main levels of courts:

  1. Supreme Court: It is the highest court in India and is located in New Delhi.
  2. High Courts: They work at the state level. India has 25 High Courts.
  3. District and Subordinate Courts: They work at the district and local levels. They include District Courts, Sessions Courts, Revenue Courts and Small Causes Courts.

The Supreme Court of India:

The Supreme Court is the highest court of law in India. It is the final authority for interpreting the Constitution.

Important Features of the Supreme Court:

Feature Details
Status Highest court of law in India.
Established 26 January 1950, when the Constitution came into effect.
Article Established under Article 124 of the Constitution.
Location New Delhi.
Head Chief Justice of India (CJI).
Strength 34 judges (1 Chief Justice + 33 other judges)
Appointment Judges are appointed by the President of India.
Retirement Age 65 years.
Motto "Yato Dharmastato Jayah" – Where there is dharma, there is victory.

Qualifications for a Supreme Court Judge:

A person must be a citizen of India and must fulfil any one of the following conditions:

  1. High Court Judge: Must have worked as a High Court judge for at least 5 years.
  2. High Court Advocate: Must have worked as an advocate in a High Court for at least 10 years.
  3. Distinguished Jurist: Must be an outstanding legal expert in the opinion of the President of India.

Remember: The Supreme Court is the highest court in India. Its main role is to protect the Constitution and ensure justice for all citizens.

Powers (Jurisdictions) of the Supreme Court:

Meaning of Jurisdiction: Jurisdiction means the power or authority of a court to hear and decide cases.

The Supreme Court has different types of jurisdiction to protect people's rights and ensure justice.

(1) Writ Jurisdiction – Articles 32 and 226:

  • Writ Jurisdiction gives the Supreme Court and High Courts the power to protect the Fundamental Rights of citizens.
  • Fundamental Rights include equality, liberty, right to life, freedom of speech and freedom of religion.
  • A person can file a Writ Petition directly in the Supreme Court or High Court.
Court Article Purpose
Supreme Court Article 32 To protect Fundamental Rights.
High Court Article 226 To protect Fundamental Rights within its state and for other legal purposes.

(2) Public Interest Litigation (PIL) – Articles 32 and 226:

Meaning of PIL:

  • PIL means Public Interest Litigation.
  • It is a legal method used to protect the rights and interests of the public.
  • A person can approach the court on behalf of people who are unable to fight for their rights.
  • PIL helps protect the Right to Life under Article 21.

First Reported PIL – Kapila Hingorani:

  • Lawyer Mrs. Kapila Hingorani read about under-trial prisoners in Bihar who had spent more time in jail than their possible punishment.
  • She filed a petition in the Supreme Court for their release.
  • The Supreme Court ordered their release and issued guidelines that helped free many under-trial prisoners across India.

Other Important PIL Cases:

Case Issue Outcome
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India Environmental protection. The Supreme Court took steps to clean the River Ganga and protect the Taj Mahal.
Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan Sexual harassment at the workplace. In 1997, the Supreme Court issued guidelines. In 2013, the government passed a law to prevent and address workplace sexual harassment.

(3) Original Jurisdiction – Article 131:

Original Jurisdiction means the power of the Supreme Court to hear certain cases directly for the first time.

The Supreme Court settles disputes between:

  1. The Central Government and one or more State Governments.
  2. The Central Government and one or more States on one side, and another State or States on the other side.
  3. Two or more State Governments, such as disputes over river water.

Meaning of Original and Exclusive:

  • Original: The case can be filed directly in the Supreme Court.
  • Exclusive: Only the Supreme Court has the authority to hear such disputes.

(4) Appellate Jurisdiction – Articles 132, 133, 134 and 134A:

  • Appellate Jurisdiction means the power of the Supreme Court to hear appeals against decisions of High Courts.
  • Appeals may be made in cases involving important questions of constitutional interpretation or law.
  • The Supreme Court can hear appeals in certain serious criminal cases, including cases involving the death sentence.
  • It can also hear appeals from certain specialised tribunals, such as the National Green Tribunal (NGT) and National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), as permitted by law.

(5) Advisory Jurisdiction – Article 143

  • The President of India can ask the Supreme Court for its opinion on important questions of law or fact.
  • The Supreme Court examines the matter and gives its advice.
  • Such matters are heard by a Constitution Bench of at least 5 judges.

(6) Special Leave Petition (SLP) – Article 136:

  • SLP means Special Leave Petition.
  • It gives the Supreme Court special power to allow an appeal against a decision of almost any court or tribunal in India.
  • It is an extraordinary and discretionary power of the Supreme Court.
  • It is used in important cases where justice needs to be done or an important legal question arises.

Binding Force and Special Powers:

Article Provision
141 The law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts within the territory of India
142 The Supreme Court can pass any order necessary for doing complete justice
144 All civil and judicial authorities shall act in aid of the Supreme Court
Quick Revision – Types of Supreme Court Jurisdiction :

Quick Revision – Types of Supreme Court Jurisdiction:

Type Article(s) Main Purpose
Writ 32 Protect Fundamental Rights.
PIL 32 and 226 Protect public interest.
Original 131 Settle disputes between governments.
Appellate 132, 133, 134, 134A Hear appeals against court decisions.
Advisory 143 Give advice to the President.
Special Leave Petition 136 Allow special appeals against court or tribunal decisions.

Remember: The Supreme Court protects the Constitution, safeguards Fundamental Rights, settles disputes and ensures justice throughout India.

[collapse]

The High Courts:

The High Court is the highest court at the State level. It supervises the courts working under it.

Important Features of High Courts:

Feature Details
Status Highest court at the State level.
Article Article 214 provides for a High Court in each State.
Number India has 25 High Courts for 28 States and 8 Union Territories. Some High Courts serve more than one State or Union Territory.
Composition Each High Court has one Chief Justice and other judges.
Appointment Judges are appointed by the President of India after consultation with the Chief Justice of India, the Governor of the State and the Chief Justice of the concerned High Court.
Qualifications A person must be an Indian citizen and must have held a judicial office for at least 10 years or been an advocate of a High Court for at least 10 years.
Retirement Age 62 years.
List of 25 High Courts and Their Territories :

List of 25 High Courts and Their Territories:

S.No. High Court States / Union Territories Covered
1 Allahabad High Court Uttar Pradesh
2 Andhra Pradesh High Court Andhra Pradesh
3 Bombay High Court Maharashtra, Goa, Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman and Diu
4 Calcutta High Court West Bengal, Andaman and Nicobar Islands
5 Chhattisgarh High Court Chhattisgarh
6 Delhi High Court Delhi
7 Gauhati High Court Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh
8 Gujarat High Court Gujarat
9 Himachal Pradesh High Court Himachal Pradesh
10 Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court Jammu and Kashmir, Ladakh
11 Jharkhand High Court Jharkhand
12 Karnataka High Court Karnataka
13 Kerala High Court Kerala, Lakshadweep
14 Madras High Court Tamil Nadu, Puducherry
15 Madhya Pradesh High Court Madhya Pradesh
16 Manipur High Court Manipur
17 Meghalaya High Court Meghalaya
18 Orissa High Court Odisha
19 Patna High Court Bihar
20 Punjab and Haryana High Court Punjab, Haryana, Chandigarh
21 Rajasthan High Court Rajasthan
22 Sikkim High Court Sikkim
23 Telangana High Court Telangana
24 Tripura High Court Tripura
25 Uttarakhand High Court Uttarakhand

[collapse]

Important Points to Remember:

  1. India has 25 High Courts.
  2. Article 214 deals with High Courts.
  3. The President appoints High Court judges.
  4. The retirement age of High Court judges is 62 years.
  5. The Bombay High Court serves Maharashtra, Goa and two Union Territories.
  6. The Punjab and Haryana High Court serves Punjab, Haryana and Chandigarh.

Shared High Courts – Must Remember:

  • Bombay → Maharashtra + Goa + Dadra & Nagar Haveli and Daman & Diu
  • Calcutta → West Bengal + Andaman & Nicobar Islands
  • Gauhati → Assam + Nagaland + Mizoram + Arunachal Pradesh
  • Kerala → Kerala + Lakshadweep
  • Madras → Tamil Nadu + Puducherry
  • Punjab & Haryana → Punjab + Haryana + Chandigarh
  • Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh → the two Union Territories together

Jurisdiction of the High Courts:

Jurisdiction means the power or authority of a court to hear and decide cases.

The High Court exercises the following powers within its territorial area:

  • Writ Jurisdiction – Article 226: The High Court can issue writs to protect Fundamental Rights and for other legal purposes.
  • Appeal Power: It hears appeals against decisions of lower courts in civil and criminal cases and certain tribunals.
  • Supervisory Control: It supervises all subordinate courts working within its territory.
  • Power of Superintendence – Article 227: It ensures that lower courts and tribunals work within their legal powers. This power is used carefully and only when necessary.
  • Basic Structure: The writ and supervisory powers of High Courts are considered part of the basic structure of the Constitution.
  • Protection of Lower Judiciary: Every High Court must maintain the honour and integrity of the subordinate courts in its State.
Supreme Court vs High Court – Comparison :

Supreme Court vs High Court – Comparison:

Point Supreme Court High Court
Level Highest court at the national level. Highest court at the State level.
Article of Establishment Article 124 Article 214
Number One, located in New Delhi. 25 High Courts in India.
Head Chief Justice of India (CJI). Chief Justice of the High Court.
Strength (Textbook) 34 judges (33 + 1). Varies from State to State.
Appointment Judges are appointed by the President of India. Appointed by the President after consultation with the CJI, Governor and Chief Justice of the concerned High Court.
Qualification High Court Judge for 5 years / High Court Advocate for 10 years / Distinguished Jurist. Judicial office or High Court Advocate for 10 years.
Retirement Age 65 years. 62 years.
Writ Jurisdiction Article 32 – Protection of Fundamental Rights. Article 226 – Protection of Fundamental Rights and other legal rights.
Special Powers Articles 131, 136, 141, 142, 143 and 144. Article 227 – Supervision of lower courts and tribunals.

[collapse]

Quick Revision:

  • Supreme Court: Highest court in India; retirement age is 65 years.
  • High Court: Highest court at the State level; retirement age is 62 years.
  • Article 226: Writ jurisdiction of High Courts.
  • Article 227: Supervisory power of High Courts.
  • Article 32: Writ jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.

Subordinate Courts and Tribunals:

Subordinate Courts :

  • Every State has a system of Subordinate Courts that work under the High Court.
  • Articles 233 to 237 of the Constitution deal with the organisation of these courts and protect their independence.
  • Subordinate courts are important because they provide justice directly to people at the district and local levels.

They include the following courts:

  • District Courts
  • Sessions Courts
  • Revenue Courts
  • Small Causes Courts

Appointment of District Judges: District Judges are appointed by the Governor of the State in consultation with the High Court (Article 233).

Tribunals:

Meaning of Tribunal: A Tribunal is a special body established to settle particular types of disputes.

Tribunals are quasi-judicial bodies. This means they work like courts and make decisions on specific legal matters.

Types of Tribunals and Their Functions :

Types of Tribunals and Their Functions:

Tribunal Main Function
Consumer Fora Settle consumer-related disputes.
Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) Handles service-related disputes of government employees.
National Green Tribunal (NGT) Deals with environmental issues.
National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) Handles company-related disputes and insolvency matters.
Armed Forces Tribunal Handles disputes related to the Armed Forces.
Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL) Deals with electricity-related disputes.

[collapse]

Important Points to Remember :

  • Subordinate Courts work under the High Courts.
  • Articles 233–237 deal with subordinate courts.
  • The Governor appoints District Judges in consultation with the High Court.
  • Tribunals settle specific types of disputes.
  • Tribunals help people get specialised and speedy justice.

New Criminal Laws and Digital Courts:

Replacement of Colonial-Era Criminal Laws (2023):

In 2023, the Indian government introduced three new criminal laws to replace old laws made during British rule.

Old Laws and Their Replacements :

Old Laws and Their Replacements:

Old Law New Law
Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860 Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023
Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973 Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023

[collapse]

Aims of the New Criminal Laws:

  • To provide faster justice.
  • To allow the use of digital evidence.
  • To provide better protection to victims.
  • To make the judicial system modern, transparent and effective.

Digital Technology and the Judicial System:

  • Digital technology has made the judicial system more accessible and transparent.
  • People involved in legal cases can directly check their case details online instead of depending only on lawyers.
  • Copies of court orders and judgments are available online, including in different Indian languages.
  • Case details can be checked through court websites and the National Judicial Data Grid (NJDG).
Digital Initiatives in the Judiciary :

Digital Initiatives in the Judiciary:

Initiative Purpose
e-Filing Allows people to file cases and documents online.
Hybrid Hearings Allows people to attend court hearings either physically or online.
Live Streaming Allows the public to watch court proceedings online.
Translation of Judgments Makes court judgments available in different Indian languages.
National Judicial Data Grid (NJDG) Provides information about pending and completed cases.
Virtual Justice Clock Displays real-time judicial information on a large screen at the Supreme Court, promoting transparency and accountability.

[collapse]

Meaning of Litigant : A Litigant is a person involved in a legal case.

Both the person who files a case (sues) and the person against whom the case is filed (gets sued) are called litigants.

Quick Revision:

  • BNS: Replaced IPC.
  • BNSS: Replaced CrPC.
  • BSA: Replaced the Indian Evidence Act.
  • e-Filing: Filing court documents online.
  • Hybrid Hearings: Online and physical court hearings.
  • NJDG: Provides information about court cases.
  • Live Streaming: Watching court proceedings online.

Alternative Modes of Dispute Resolution (ADR) :

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) means settling disputes without going through lengthy court proceedings.

  • Courts encourage ADR to reduce their workload.
  • It helps people settle disputes quickly and peacefully.
  • Main methods include arbitration, mediation, Lok Adalat and Gram Nyayalayas.

(1) Arbitration:

  • In arbitration, both parties agree to refer their dispute to an independent person called an arbitrator.
  • An arbitrator may be a retired judge, lawyer or expert.
  • The arbitrator must act fairly and give both parties an opportunity to present their cases.
  • The decision is final and legally binding. It can be enforced by a court.
  • It is governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

(2) Mediation:

  • Mediation is one of the most common methods of ADR.
  • A neutral person called a mediator helps both parties reach a mutual agreement.
  • The mediator does not give a decision or force either party to accept a solution.
  • It is governed by the Mediation Act, 2023.

(3) Lok Adalats:

  • Lok Adalats are special courts where disputes are settled peacefully.
  • They can settle cases pending in courts. In some cases, people can approach them before going to court.
  • They are also called People's Courts.
  • They provide easy access to justice and reduce the burden on regular courts.
  • They are recognised under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987.

(4) Gram Nyayalayas:

  • Gram Nyayalayas are village-level courts established under the Gram Nyayalayas Act, 2008.
  • Their aim is to make justice easily available to people in villages.
  • They help reduce the burden on regular courts.
  • They work as mobile courts and follow simple procedures without unnecessary technicalities.
ADR at a Glance :

ADR at a Glance:

Mode Who helps or decides? Nature of decision Governing law
Arbitration Arbitrator or panel of arbitrators Final and legally binding Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996
Mediation Parties themselves, with help from a mediator Mutual agreement; mediator cannot impose a decision Mediation Act, 2023
Lok Adalat Parties reach a peaceful settlement Amicable settlement Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987
Gram Nyayalaya Village-level mobile court Decision through a simplified procedure Gram Nyayalayas Act, 2008

[collapse]

Quick Revision:

  • Arbitration: An arbitrator gives a binding decision.
  • Mediation: A mediator helps parties reach an agreement.
  • Lok Adalat: People's Court that settles disputes peacefully.
  • Gram Nyayalaya: Simple village-level court.
Key Features of Kitabcd Exam Master :

  • Big Questions, Let’s Explore, Think about It, Don’t Miss Out/Intext Questions with Solutions,
  • Exercise Questions with Solutions.
  • Objective Type Questions with Answers
  • Activities with answers.
  • Exam Oriented Questions and Answers
  • Case/Source Based Questions
PDF Links

Rs 10 ncert 8

-Kitabcd Academy Offer-

Buy Notes(Rs.5)+ Exam Master (Rs.7) - (2 PDF) of this chapter
Price : Rs.12 / Rs.10

Click on below button to buy PDF in discounted price

Click on below links to get PDF from store

PDF : Class-8-Social Science-II-Chapter-4-The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society– Notes

PDF : Class-8-Social Science-II-Chapter-4-The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society– Exam Master


NCERT-Class 8 Social Science -1 PDF Set :

Class -8-Social Science-1-All Chapter’s Notes Set (7-PDF)-Rs.35

Class -8-Social Science-1-All Chapter’s Exam Master Set (7-PDF)-Rs.45

Class -8-Social Science-1-All Chapter’s Notes + Exam Master Set (14-PDF)-Rs.65

Useful Links

Main Page : NCERT-Class-8-Social Science (Exploring Society: India and Beyond) – All chapters notes, solutions, videos, test, pdf.

Previous Chapter : Chapter-3-A Journey Through Indian Architecture – Online Notes

Next Chapter : Chapter-5- Citizenship: Rights and Duties – Online Notes

Leave a Reply

Write your suggestions, questions in comment box

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We reply to valid query.